| 1923 - 1924 - Robert L. Earnest | Fall 1956 - William T. Basford | Fall 1984 - Reginald Garcia |
| 1924 - 1925 - Carroll W. Fussell | Spring 1957 - Thomas F. Byrd | Spring 1985 - Robert Stern |
| 1925 - 1926 - Murray W. Overstreet, Sr. | Fall 1957 - Stephen W. Sessums | Fall 1985 - Charles Carver |
| 1926 - 1927 - Olin E. Watts | Spring 1958 - Jack F. Shostein | Spring 1986 - Alex Abreu, Michael Simon |
| 1927 - 1928 - Ernest Edward Mason | Fall 1958 - Tom W. McAliley, Jr. | Fall 1986 - Timothy Shulte |
| 1928 - 1929 - Donald Ray Matthews | Spring 1959 - Donald Bolting | Spring 1987 - William Penn Dawson, III |
| 1929 - 1930 - Charles S. Ausley | Fall 1959 - Thomas Henderson | Fall 1987 - Alton Lightsey |
| 1930 - 1931 - William G. Carlton | Spring 1960 - John Robed McClure | Spring 1988 - Robert Sprole |
| 1931 - 1932 - Lawrence Walrath | Fall 1960 - Norman H. Lipoff | Fall 1988 - Tate Taylor |
| 1932 - 1933 - Winston E. Arnow | Spring 1961 - David Strawn | Spring 1989 - Glenn Tootle |
| Fall 1933 - Jack Levick Peters | Fall 1961 - J.S Quincey & Carter Braddock | Fall 1989 - Glenn Tootle |
| Spring 1934 - William C. Sherrill | Spring 1962 - Jack Shreve | Spring 1990 - Ernie Cox |
| Fall 1934 - T. Paine Kelly, Jr. | Fall 1962 - Jackson Olin Brownlee | Fall 1990 - Kelly Geraghty |
| Spring 1935 - John Mercer Brown | Spring 1963 - Robert Hendry | Spring 1991 - Tad Delegal |
| Fall 1935 - William C. Lantaft | Fall 1963 - Stephen David Gardner | Fall 1991 - Debra Grassgreen |
| Spring 1936 - Willard W. Ayres | Spring 1964 - Charles T. Wells | Spring 1992 - Jim Daniel |
| Fall 1936 - Jule Brown Patterson | Fall 1964 - Ronald C. LaFace | Fall 1992 - Pat Siracusa |
| Spring 1937 - John U. Lloyd | Spring 1965 - Woodrow "Mac" Melvin, Jr. | Spring 1993 - Rick Alexander |
| Fall 1937 - I. Ben Krentzman | Fall 1965 - Stewart F. Parsons | Fall 1993 - Bruce Harris |
| Spring 1938 - Seldon F. Waldo | Spring 1966 - Bruce Starling | Spring 1994 - Edward Jennings, Jr. |
| Fall 1938 - Robert M. Barton | Fall 1966 - Barry Sinoff | Fall 1994 - Joseph Touger |
| Spring 1939 - Clifford C. Beasley | Spring 1967 - K.B. "Chip" Block, Jr. | Spring 1995 - Jennifer Wilson |
| Fall 1939 - George C. Young | Fall 1967 - Charles B. Edwards | Fall 1995 - Christopher Meyer |
| Spring 1940 - Stephen C. O'Connell | Spring 1968 - Ira William "Bill" McColllum, Jr. | Spring 1996 - Christopher Nash |
| Fall 1940 - William C. Grimes | Fall 1968 - John B. Ritch | Fall 1996 - Vivian Quesada |
| Spring 1941 - Raymond Ehrlich | Spring 1969 - Manuel W. James | Spring 1997 - Julie Imanuel |
| Fall 1941 - Homer E. Still, Jr. | Fall 1969 - John F. Harkness, Jr. | Fall 1997 - Ronald LaFace, Jr. |
| Spring 1942 - Fletcher Rush | Spring 1970 - Don Middlebrooks | Spring 1998 - Joshua Weingard |
| Fall 1942 - James W. Norman, Jr. | Fall 1970 - Stephen N. Zack | Fall 1998 - J. Ryan Chandler IV |
| Spring 1943 - Randolph Y. Matheny | Spring 1971 - Jeff Warren | Spring 1999 - J. Ryan Chandler IV |
| Fall 1943 - None | Fall 1971 - Franklin Harrisson | Fall 1999 - Ashley B. Moody |
| Spring 1944 - None | Spring 1972 - John T. O'Shea | Spring 2000 - Paul Bernstein |
| Fall 1944 - None | Fall 1972 - Ronald Leon Bloom | Fall 2000 - David J. Heekin |
| Spring 1945 - None | Spring 1973 - S. Daniel Ponce | Spring 2001 - Clay B. Sweger |
| Fall 1945 - Nixon Butt, Jr. | Fall 1973 - R. Charles "Bob" Wattle | Fall 2001 - Leslie A. Press |
| Spring 1946 - Nixon Butt, Jr. | Spring 1974 - James Reinman | Spring 2002 - Troy Finnegan, Darryl Stangry |
| Fall 1946 - Frank Austin Duckworth | Fall 1974 - Robert Andrew Heekin | Fall 2002 - E. Colin Thompson |
| Spring 1947 - Paul G. Rogers | Spring 1975 - Ronald A. David | Spring 2003 - Richard Rosenblatt |
| Fall 1947 - Mark Hulsey, Jr. | Fall 1975 - Gerald B. Currington | Fall 2003 - Karen Persis |
| Spring 1948 - Raymer F. Maguire, Jr. | Spring 1976 - Howell W. Melton, Jr. | Spring 2004 - Michael Silver |
| Fall 1948 - William Christie | Fall 1976 - Warren Wilson III | Fall 2004 - Josh Aubuchon |
| Spring 1949 - Henry Gardner | Spring 1977 - John N. Bryant | Spring 2005 - Brian Roof |
| Fall 1949 - Charles J. Hardee, Jr. | Fall 1977 - W. Michael Heekin | Fall 2005 - Brian Roof |
| Spring 1950 - Al J. Cone | Spring 1978 - William F. Quattlebaum | Spring 2006 - Pedro M. Allende |
| Fall 1950 - William Byrd | Fall 1978 - James C. Cunningham | Fall 2006 - Lauren Fackender |
| Spring 1951 - Marshall M. Criser | Spring 1979 - James H. Adair | Spring 2007 - Andrew R. Comiter |
| Fall 1951 - Leon Handley | Fall 1979 - Phillip Roberts | Fall 2007 - Andrew R. Comiter |
| Spring 1952 - Lames L. King | Spring 1980 - Russell Divine | Spring 2008 - Andrew R. Comiter |
| Fall 1952 - John Robert Terry | Fall 1980 - John Delany | Fall 2008 - G. Tyler Parramore |
| Spring 1953 - Edward Booth | Spring 1981 - T. Geoffrey Heekin | Spring 2009 - Aron M. Weingard |
| Fall 1953 - William Joseph Reynolds | Fall 1981 - Paul R. Linder | Fall 2009 - Jenny Cohen |
| Spring 1954 - Julian O. Clarkson | Spring 1982 - John B. Morgan | Spring 2010 - Stephen A. Liverpool |
| Fall 1954 - James W. Kynes, Jr. | Fall 1982 - Steven Robertson | Fall 2010 - Justin Stone |
| Spring 1955 - Charles Henry Damsel, Jr. | Spring 1983 - Randal M. Alligood | Spring 2011 - Craig P. Thompson |
| Fall 1955 - John Baker | Fall 1983 - Mark W. Merrill | Fall 2011 - Craig P. Thompson |
| Spring 1956 - Richard Pettigrew | Spring 1984 - Craig Boudreau |